Limit Order vs Market Order for Your First Trade
My first ETF purchase, back in 2014, cost me $31 more than it should have. I placed a market order for 60 shares at 9:31 in the morning because that was my lunch break at a job on the west coast, and the fund opened in a gap that closed...

My first ETF purchase, back in 2014, cost me $31 more than it should have. I placed a market order for 60 shares at 9:31 in the morning because that was my lunch break at a job on the west coast, and the fund opened in a gap that closed within four minutes. I did not know what a bid ask spread was. I just saw a confirmation that read 0.42 percent higher than the number I had looked at the night before.
That $31 is not going to change anyone's retirement. But the habit behind it will, because the same confusion shows up again every time you add money, and a $31 mistake twelve times a year for thirty years is not a rounding error. The order type box on your brokerage screen is the smallest decision on the page and the one nobody explains.
What the two order types actually do
A market order says fill me now at whatever price is available. A limit order says fill me only at this price or better, and wait otherwise.
The price you see quoted is really two prices. The bid is what buyers are currently willing to pay, the ask is what sellers want, and the gap between them is the spread. When you place a market order to buy, you pay the ask. When you sell with a market order, you receive the bid. That spread is a real cost that never shows up on any statement as a fee.
On a broad US total market ETF trading tens of millions of shares a day, that spread is usually a penny on a share price around $120, which is 0.008 percent. On a thinly traded sector or single country fund, I have seen 18 cents on a $43 share price, which is 0.42 percent. Same screen, same button, cost difference of more than fifty times.
A limit order protects you from the spread widening and from a sudden move between your click and the fill. What it cannot do is guarantee you own anything. If the price never touches your limit, the order sits unfilled until it expires, and your cash sits there with it.
Which one fits which purchase
| What you are buying | Order type I use | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Mutual fund, index or active | Neither applies | Mutual funds fill once a day at the 4pm net asset value, so there is no order type to choose |
| Broad market ETF, mid session | Market | Spread of a penny or two, and the simplicity is worth more than the penny |
| Broad market ETF, first or last 15 minutes | Limit | Spreads widen at the open and close, sometimes by a factor of five |
| Narrow sector, small country or new ETF | Limit | Spreads of 10 to 50 basis points are common and your own order can move the price |
| Individual stock, any size position | Limit | Earnings gaps and news move single names far more than a 500 stock basket |
| Anything on a day the market is down 3 percent or more | Limit | Volatility pulls ETF prices away from the value of the holdings underneath |
Notice how much of that table is about timing rather than order type. The 11am to 3pm window matters more than the box you tick. I moved my own recurring contribution from 9:30 to 11:45 in 2019 and the average gap between my fill price and that day's closing price dropped from about 11 basis points to under 4, measured across the 68 purchases I have logged since.
Why "always use a limit order" is advice that costs people money
Search for this question and you will find a near unanimous answer: never use market orders, always set a limit. I think that is wrong for most people buying broad index ETFs, and I say that as someone who uses limit orders for roughly a third of my own trades.
Here is the arithmetic nobody does. Suppose you set a limit a dime below the current ask on a $120 share price to save 0.08 percent. Some fraction of the time the price drifts up instead, your order expires, and you come back two days later to buy at $121.40. You saved eight basis points on the fills that worked and paid 117 basis points on the one that did not. Across a year of monthly contributions, the unfilled orders usually swamp the savings.
There is a behavioral cost too, and in my experience it is bigger than the money. An unfilled limit order turns an automatic investment into a decision you have to revisit. Revisiting decisions is how a contribution becomes a maybe, and a maybe becomes cash sitting in a settlement fund for five months. I have watched that happen to two people I helped set up accounts, both of whom are sharper about money than I am.
The version of the advice that holds up is narrower. Use a limit order when the spread is wide enough to matter, which you can read off your own screen before you click, and use market orders when it is a penny and you want the money invested today.
How to check the spread before you click
Your brokerage shows it, though sometimes you have to look. On the quote page, find the bid and the ask. Subtract, then divide by the ask. That number in percent is what a market order costs you one way.
My own rule, which is arbitrary but has held up for eleven years: under 0.05 percent I use a market order, over that I use a limit set at the current ask, sometimes called a marketable limit. Setting the limit at the ask rather than below it means I almost always get filled immediately, but I am protected if something strange happens in the second between my click and the exchange.
Two other boxes matter on that screen. Time in force should be day for almost everything, because a good till cancelled order can fill weeks later on news you have not seen. And if your broker offers dollar based buying, that interacts with order types in ways worth knowing before you rely on it, which I covered in the piece on fractional shares and investing with just a few dollars.
The order type I tell people to avoid entirely
Stop loss orders. These convert to market orders once a trigger price is hit, which sounds like protection and behaves like the opposite during the exact events it is meant to protect you from.
On the morning of August 24, 2015, a cluster of ETFs traded at prices far below the value of the stocks they held, some by 20 percent or more, for a matter of minutes. Stop loss orders fired into that hole and sold at those prices. The funds recovered within the hour. The sellers did not get to.
If you are holding broad index funds for twenty years, a stop loss is a mechanism for turning a bad morning into a permanent loss. Keep the holding and keep the contribution schedule.
One thing worth doing this week: open your brokerage, pull up the fund you contribute to, and write down the bid, the ask and the time of day. Do it again at 11:30 and at 3:55. Three numbers, five minutes total, and you will know which order type your own holding needs rather than taking a forum's word for it. If you have not set the account up yet, start with what a brokerage account actually is and how to open one, and if you are still choosing between fund structures, ETF vs mutual fund covers why one of these decisions disappears entirely if you pick the mutual fund.
FAQ
Does the order type matter for mutual funds?
No. Mutual fund orders placed before the market close all fill at that day's net asset value, calculated once at 4pm eastern. There is no bid, no ask and no spread, which is one genuine advantage of mutual funds for someone who finds the trade screen stressful.
What counts as a reasonable bid ask spread?
For the largest broad market ETFs, one or two cents on a share price above $50, which works out under 0.05 percent. Anything above 0.20 percent is worth a limit order, and anything above 0.50 percent on a fund you plan to buy monthly is a reason to look for a larger fund tracking the same index.
Can I use limit orders with automatic recurring investments?
Usually not. Most brokers execute recurring ETF purchases as market orders at a set time, often at or shortly after the open. If that bothers you, check whether your broker lets you choose the execution window, and if it does not, the mutual fund version of the same index removes the problem.
What time of day is best to buy an ETF?
Mid session, roughly 11am to 3pm eastern, when spreads are tightest and the market makers pricing the fund can see the prices of everything inside it. Avoid the first and last fifteen minutes, and avoid the first hour after a holiday weekend.
More in Investing for Beginners
Investing for Beginners
Fractional Shares and How to Invest With Just a Few Dollars
You want to start investing, but one share of the company or fund you have in mind costs $450, and you have $50 to spare this...
Investing for Beginners
How to Rebalance a Portfolio and How Often to Do It
You set up a simple mix of stock and bond funds a few years ago, and now your statement shows something you never chose.
Investing for Beginners
How Dividend Reinvestment Works and When to Turn It On
Your first fund paid a dividend of $14.27, it landed in your account as cash, and now you are not sure whether to leave it...